414 guides across 21 subjects
Every figure traced to a named source
Prices in Ugandan shillings, per acre and per animal

Disc Plough vs Disc Harrow

A tractor fitted with a front loader

A disc plough is a primary tillage implement: it cuts a slice of soil at depth, lifts it and turns it over, burying trash and opening compacted ground. A disc harrow works shallower, chopping clods and levelling what the plough left so seed can be placed evenly. Choosing between a disc plough and a disc harrow is really choosing which of those two jobs the field needs next.

How a Disc Plough Cuts and Inverts Farm Soil

Look at the mounting and the rest follows. Every disc on a plough sits on its own stub axle, free to turn independently, carried on its own standard off the frame. Two angles are set on each one. The disc angle is how far the plane of the cutting edge is turned away from the direction of travel, and published work on standard disc ploughs puts it around 42 to 45 degrees. The tilt angle is how far that plane leans back from vertical, commonly in the range of 15 to 25 degrees. Between them those two settings decide whether the disc slices in cleanly or skates, and reducing the tilt angle improves penetration, which is why a plough that will not bite is often a plough with its tilt set wrong rather than a plough behind too small a tractor.

Plough discs are large. Diameters of roughly 60 to 90 cm are normal, and that size sets the ceiling on depth, because a disc can only work a fraction of its own diameter. A standard disc plough reaches somewhere around 250 to 300 mm at most. Two to five discs on a frame is the usual span for the tractor sizes Uganda runs.

Independent mounting is the quality that matters most on Ugandan land. Each disc can ride up over a root or a stone and settle back into work without taking the frame with it. That tolerance is exactly why discs, rather than mouldboards, dominate tillage in this region, and MAAIF's own operating guidance still tells tractor operators to walk a field and check for tree stumps, roots and rocks before ploughing it. Scrapers bolted beside each disc keep the concave face clear in soil sticky enough to build up on it.

What the plough hands over is a furrow, an inverted slice with the residue underneath it, and a surface of large clods at uneven height. Those clods are not a fault. They are the signature of the operation, and they are the next implement's problem.

How a Disc Harrow Breaks Clods and Levels a Seedbed

A harrow is built the opposite way round. Its discs are smaller, roughly 40 to 60 cm, and none of them is mounted individually. They are threaded onto a common square shaft, the gang bolt, separated by spacer spools and clamped tight so the whole gang of discs turns as one piece. Ten to twenty eight discs across an implement is ordinary.

Two consequences fall straight out of that. You cannot set the angle of a single disc, only the angle of the whole gang relative to travel, so the harrow has one coarse adjustment where the plough has two fine ones per disc. And a gang cannot dodge anything: meet a buried root and the entire gang lifts, which is why a harrow is the wrong first implement on land that has not been cleared.

Aggression in a harrow comes from a list of variables rather than from one setting. USDA SARE's field guide to tillage tools puts it as blade diameter, blade weight, blade concavity, blade spacing, the angle of the gang to the direction of travel, and operating speed. Larger blades, wider spacing, higher speed and a bigger gang angle are all more aggressive. Everything the implement does to the soil is a combination of those six.

The output is different in kind, not just in degree: residue cut and partly mixed into the top layer, clods reduced, ridges knocked down, and a surface firm enough that seed sits against moist soil instead of in an air pocket.

Using a Disc Harrow Where the Soil Needs a Plough

This is the expensive mistake, and it is expensive slowly, which is why it keeps happening. A harrow that gets used season after season as the only tillage implement works the same shallow band of soil every time. Below that band nothing is loosened, and it is worse than merely untouched, because the pressure and the smearing of repeated passes above compress it.

FAO's soils bulletin on soil porosity states the mechanism without hedging. Continual use of tillage implements, and it names disc ploughs, disc harrows, mouldboard ploughs and rotovators together, frequently produces dense plough pans containing few pores large enough for crop roots to enter. Those pans develop just below the depth to which the soil is tilled. In mechanised systems they usually form between 12 and 30 cm down, according to the implement and the depth it normally works. And the sentence that should settle the argument for anyone running discs only: repeated use of disc equipment, especially heavy duty disc harrows, can produce an almost impermeable compacted pan in only a few seasons. In Brazil those pans drove increasingly severe runoff and erosion across millions of hectares before farmers dropped disc equipment for tine implements and then for no tillage.

The same thing happens without a tractor anywhere in sight. Field observations from Malawi, Zambia and Tanzania record that repeated hoeing to one depth builds a pan at the base of the hoed layer. Hoe pans typically sit just 5 to 8 cm down and can be only 2 to 3 cm thick, which is thin enough to look like nothing in a pit face and hard enough to turn a taproot sideways. Where mounds or ridges are rebuilt in the same place every year, feet walking the furrows in wet weather add to it.

Why this costs a Ugandan farm more than the word compaction suggests comes down to two things. Rooting is confined to the layer above the pan, so a crop with only a hundred millimetres of soil available runs out of water after a few dry days in what looks like a good season. And water that cannot get down runs off instead, taking soil with it.

There are Ugandan measurements of exactly that. A trial led from Makerere University's college of agriculture, on Lixic Ferralsols in Mukono District, ran bounded runoff plots under four tillage systems across two wet seasons, comparing no tillage, stubble mulch, conventional tillage and deep tillage using a three furrow plough. On the steeper of the two sites, conventional tillage at 15 cm worked down the slope shed 80.4 percent of the season's rainfall as surface runoff. The no tillage plots on the same site, in the same season, shed 21.1 percent. Suspended sediment averaged 2.41 grams per litre under conventional tillage against 0.65 under no tillage, giving sediment losses of about 171 against 12 kilograms per hectare for that season. Infiltration and stored soil moisture were both highest under no tillage and lowest under conventional tillage, and every one of those differences was large enough to be statistically reliable.

Read those numbers as what they are. They come from small bounded plots on slopes of 10 and 15 percent, so the percentages are plot measurements rather than a whole farm water balance. What transfers is the size and direction of the gap: the more the soil surface was opened and inverted and left bare, the less of the rain stayed on the farm.

One more result from the same trial is free to act on. Working across the slope instead of down it lowered runoff at every tillage level tested, on both sites, in both seasons.

How to find out whether your field already has a pan, with a spade and ten minutes.
Dig a pit, do not auger one. Open a hole about 40 cm deep with one clean vertical face, between crop rows, in a part of the field that has been tilled the same way for years.
Push a wire or a knife down the face. Feel for a band where resistance jumps and then eases again below it. That band is the pan. Note its depth against the depth you normally till, because a pan sits just under it.
Look at the roots, not the soil. Roots that drop straight, then turn and run sideways along a level are the clearest evidence there is. A taproot that flattens into an L has hit something.
Look at the face itself. A pan often shows a smooth, sealed upper surface with the pores closed over, and the soil above it may break into plates rather than crumbs.
Watch the field after rain. Water standing in the furrows long after the rain stopped, or a field that runs off while the topsoil is still dry underneath, both point at restricted permeability below.
Check more than one spot. Headlands and gateways compact from traffic rather than from tillage, so sample the middle of the field along with the edges before deciding what caused it.

Using a Disc Plough Where a Harrow Would Do: Wasted Fuel and Soil Damage

The reverse mistake is cheaper, and still not cheap. Ploughing a field that only needed levelling is a straightforward transfer of money to a fuel pump.

MAAIF's own costing model for a tractor hire service is useful here because it publishes its assumptions. For a 60 to 80 horsepower tractor it assumes 15 litres of diesel an hour and 2.5 hours to plough a hectare. Multiply those and ploughing a hectare burns about 37 to 38 litres, which is roughly 15 litres for an acre. That is arithmetic from MAAIF's own inputs rather than a measured figure, and it will move with soil, depth and operator. Every unnecessary ploughing pass is that fuel again, plus the share of bearing, disc and standard wear the pass consumed.

Time behaves the same way. At 2.5 hours a hectare the plough is doing about an hour an acre. A harrow at the same tractor power covers far more ground per hour, because it is shallower, lighter in draught and run faster. Swapping a plough pass for a harrow pass on land that did not need inverting buys back both the fuel and the days.

Then the agronomy, which is the part that outlasts the season. Ploughing a field that only needed a seedbed brings subsoil clods up and buries the moist, biologically active topsoil underneath them. The rough finish then has to be fixed with extra harrow passes, and FAO's porosity work notes that compaction becomes more likely precisely when farmers use many passes to prepare a seedbed. You pay twice: once for the unnecessary plough pass and again for the passes needed to repair it.

It would be convenient if the lesson were that ploughing is safe and harrowing is dangerous. It is not. FAO names disc ploughs first in its list of pan forming implements, and its review of farm power in sub Saharan Africa says flatly that the tractor mounted disc plough is responsible for immense environmental damage in the region, where tractor power goes almost entirely into primary cultivation with disc ploughs. A plough builds a pan at its own working depth just as a harrow builds one at its. What protects the soil is varying the depth between seasons, cutting the number of passes, and keeping residue on the surface. It is not the choice of implement.

Offset and Tandem Disc Harrows for Ugandan Farms

Harrows come in two frame layouts and they are not interchangeable.

A tandem harrow carries four gangs arranged like a bowtie. The two front gangs lead with their outer ends ahead, angling back toward the centre, and the two rear gangs mirror them with their inner ends leading. Side forces cancel, the implement runs straight behind the tractor and leaves a level finish. SARE records gang angle on tandems as commonly fixed at 18 or 20 degrees, or adjustable to something less.

An offset harrow has two straight gangs, one behind the other, on a strong central frame, angled in opposite directions. Its gang angle adjusts over a wider range, and the whole implement runs to one side of the tractor rather than directly behind it, which is where the name comes from and why it earns its place along plantation edges, beside boundaries and under tree canopies where the tractor has to stay out of the worked strip.

Here is the part that complicates the clean plough against harrow story, and it is worth knowing before you buy either. SARE notes that offset harrows fitted with heavier blades, up to around 28 inches, are used more often for primary tillage and in heavy residue. A heavy offset disc is genuinely a primary tillage implement. For a field that needs more than levelling but does not need full inversion, it is a real third option, and one that the disc plough against disc harrow framing tends to hide. What it costs you is weight: draught goes up, the linkage lift requirement goes up, and the implement is less forgiving to handle in a small field.

For a smallholding the practical split is simple enough. A tandem finishes seedbeds on reasonably level ground and gives the best surface for a planter. An offset does heavier work, handles more residue and fits places a tandem cannot go.

Disc Size, Spacing and Weight Per Disc in Hard Soil

Penetration is not a horsepower question. A tractor with power to spare will still leave a harrow riding on the surface of a dry clay, because what forces a disc into hard ground is mass and geometry.

Diameter. Bigger discs can reach deeper, and need proportionally more weight above them to get there. Fitting larger blades to a light frame buys nothing.
Spacing. Wider spacing between blades works deeper and more aggressively but leaves a coarser surface. A common tandem pattern is 22 inch blades on 9 inch spacing, which is a compromise toward finish rather than depth.
Weight per blade. The number that decides whether the implement digs at all in dry conditions, and the reason ballast boxes and weight trays exist on harrow frames. A harrow that will not penetrate needs mass, not a bigger tractor.
Concavity. A deeper dish throws and mixes more soil and pulls harder. A flatter blade cuts with less disturbance.
Blade edge. Notched blades cut through trash and crop residue better; plain edged blades leave a smoother finish in clean fields. Many implements carry notched blades on the front gangs and plain on the rear.
Wear. Discs lose diameter and edge as they wear, and a worn set simply stops penetrating. Measure an in service disc against a new one of the same part number before blaming the tractor. Bearings, spacer spools and the straightness of the gang bolt belong in the same inspection, and the routine for it sits in the farm equipment maintenance guide.
Soil moisture. The master variable over all of the above. Both implements have a narrow window: too dry and nothing penetrates no matter how much steel you add, too wet and you compact the soil while appearing to work it.

Number of Discs and the Tractor Horsepower Your Farm Needs

The published rules of thumb for matching implement size to tractor power disagree with each other badly, and pretending otherwise would be dishonest. Figures in circulation run from roughly 15 to 30 horsepower per plough bottom, through one horsepower per inch of working width, to a flat twenty per disc. That spread is not carelessness. Draught in a moist Ugandan clay worked at 250 mm is a different physical problem from a sandy loam at 150 mm, and no single multiplier covers both.

So do not buy from a rule of thumb. Get two numbers instead. The first is the implement maker's stated minimum tractor power for that exact model at that exact working width, which is a claim the seller can be held to. The second is the implement's mass against your tractor's lift capacity measured at the ball ends, because a mounted implement you can pull but cannot lift is unusable at the headland. How engine power, drawbar pull and lift capacity relate to one another is worked through under tractor horsepower explained.

One claim circulating on equipment pages deserves rejecting outright: that a disc plough needs at least 85 horsepower. That is one product's specification presented as a rule for the whole class, and taken seriously it would write off every small mounted plough working behind a Category 1 or light Category 2 tractor in Uganda today. Ask about the model in front of you, not about disc ploughs in general.

For a scale check from a source with nothing to sell, USDA SARE's comparison model for a 21 foot drawn tandem disc harrow lists recommended shaft power of 120 to 170 horsepower at 4 to 8 miles an hour. That works out near 6 to 8 horsepower per foot of width for a heavy drawn implement run fast, which is a sanity check on a quotation rather than a specification for a small mounted harrow. If a seller's figure sits far outside that neighbourhood once you adjust for depth and speed, ask why.

A last practical point. More discs is not more capacity if the tractor cannot hold working depth. A tractor at its limit slips, and wheel slip costs fuel while pressing the soil you just loosened back down. A narrower implement that holds depth beats a wider one that does not.

Breaking an Existing Hardpan Before the Planting Season

If the pit test found a pan, neither a plough nor a harrow is the right first answer, and the remedy depends on how deep the pan sits. FAO's porosity bulletin sets it out by depth.

Shallow pans of the kind hoeing produces, at 5 to 8 cm, come apart under an ox drawn ripper or a tractor mounted chisel plough. Where no draught power is available at all the option is double digging by hand, which works and is very labour intensive. Breaking a pan in the dry season needs tools heavier than the ones used for normal tillage: a pickaxe, a mattock, a three tined hoe or a long crowbar.

Plough pans sit deeper, usually within the top 10 to 25 cm. Pans formed by ox drawn implements usually come apart under two passes of an ox drawn ripper. Pans formed by tractor drawn or tractor mounted implements usually need a tractor mounted subsoiler. Position the subsoiler shanks immediately behind the tractor's wheels, so the pass lifts the very soil the wheels have just pressed down.

Timing is the hard part, and it is a genuine conflict rather than an oversight. Subsoiling does no good when the pan is wet or even very moist, because the soil deforms instead of shattering and closes back up behind the shank. But dry season soil may be too hard to enter with the equipment available, which pushes the job toward the first rains, exactly when the tractor is wanted for land preparation. The workable answer is to plan the pass a season ahead rather than discovering the pan at planting.

Two cautions before anyone books a subsoiler. A disc plough can be used to break a pan, and FAO says so, but it inverts as it goes, bringing large subsoil clods to the surface and leaving ground rough enough to need extra tillage afterwards. And loosened soil is more vulnerable to compaction than it was before, so heavy traffic or a run of extra passes after subsoiling can leave the field in a worse state than the original pan. Lighten the traffic afterwards or the money is wasted.

Biology does part of the job cheaply. Crop rotations that put deep rooting species into the sequence open channels through dense layers, and FAO reports Tephrosia vogelii being used in Malawi as a biological subsoiler that breaks up hardpan while producing biomass and fixing nitrogen. None of that is quick, and none of it replaces mechanical loosening under a severe pan, but it slows the pan from reforming.

It is worth knowing how unusual the alternative still is here. Figures compiled by the African Conservation Tillage Network with FAO put Uganda's cropland under conservation agriculture at about 7,800 hectares, against roughly 6.9 million hectares of cropland in total, which is around 0.11 percent. Almost every Ugandan field is still prepared by inversion tillage, so pan risk is a majority condition rather than an edge case. Checking what the soil itself is short of, while the pit is open, saves a second trip: the method is under soil testing before fertilizer application.

Choosing Between a Disc Plough and a Disc Harrow for Your Soil

Question Disc plough Disc harrow
Tillage stage Primary Secondary
Disc diameter About 60 to 90 cm About 40 to 60 cm
Disc mounting Individual stub axle Gang on a shared bolt
Working depth Up to about 250 to 300 mm Shallow, top layer only
Soil action Cuts, lifts, inverts Cuts, breaks, levels
Field left behind Furrows and large clods Level, firm seedbed
Obstruction tolerance Rides over singly Whole gang lifts
Passes per season Usually one One or two

The table settles the easy cases. What follows are the ones where the obvious answer is wrong.

Field cultivated last season, only annual weeds showing. Harrow alone. Skipping the plough is the correct call here, not a corner cut, and it saves both the fuel and a pass of compaction.
Pit test found a pan. Neither implement first. Ripper or subsoiler, at the right moisture, then normal tillage afterwards.
New land, or grass with a matted root layer. Plough, and budget for two harrow passes after it. Do not attempt this with a harrow.
Ground dry and hard after a long dry spell. Neither will penetrate properly. You will burn diesel and polish steel. Wait for moisture, or accept a shallow pass and plan a deeper one later.
Ground wet. Stop. Both implements compact wet soil, and the damage sits below where you can see it.
Stones or stumps still in the field. Discs rather than a mouldboard, and travel slowly. A gang harrow is the worst choice on uncleared land.
Sloping field. Work across the slope rather than down it, whichever implement is on the back. The Mukono trial measured lower runoff from perpendicular tillage at every tillage level it tested.
Money for one implement only. If the land is already cultivated, buy the harrow and hire ploughing. If it is not, buy the plough and hire harrowing. Where each implement sits in the season, and what else the set needs, is mapped under tractor implements explained.
Under about two acres. A tractor implement may be the wrong scale entirely. Look at power tillers for small farms first, and at whether hiring a plough pass once a year covers the primary tillage you need.

Both implements sit inside a wider set of choices about machine size and ownership, covered across the farm machinery guides and, for the tractor itself, under choosing a tractor.

Disc Plough and Disc Harrow Questions from Ugandan Farms

Can a disc harrow replace a disc plough? Not for primary tillage. A harrow works the top layer, cannot open compacted or grass bound ground, and used alone season after season builds a compacted pan just below its working depth. FAO records that repeated use of disc equipment, and heavy duty disc harrows in particular, can produce an almost impermeable pan within a few seasons.

How deep does each implement actually work? A standard disc plough reaches roughly 250 to 300 mm, with disc diameter setting the limit because a disc works a fraction of its own size. A disc harrow works the shallow surface layer, which is the point of it. Neither figure is fixed: soil moisture, implement weight and disc wear all move it.

How do I know if my field has a hardpan? Dig a pit about 40 cm deep with one clean vertical face, push a wire or knife down it and feel for a band where resistance jumps then eases, and look for roots that turn and run sideways along a level. A pan will sit just below the depth you normally till, so in mechanised fields expect it somewhere between 12 and 30 cm, and in hand hoed fields as shallow as 5 to 8 cm.

Which costs more per acre to run, ploughing or harrowing? Ploughing, by a wide margin, because it is deeper, heavier in draught and slower. MAAIF's illustrated hire costing model assumes 15 litres of fuel an hour and 2.5 hours to plough a hectare for a 60 to 80 horsepower tractor, which comes to about 37 to 38 litres a hectare, or roughly 15 litres an acre of diesel for the ploughing pass alone. The same model prices a ploughing pass at about UGX 71,700 an acre once ownership, repairs, fuel, lubricant and labour are all counted, but it assumes a pump price of UGX 4,000 a litre that no longer holds, so re run it at the current price. A harrow pass at the same tractor power covers more ground per litre.

What does a disc plough or disc harrow cost in Uganda? There is no single answer worth printing. Price moves with the number of discs, disc diameter, frame steel thickness, whether the implement is imported new, locally fabricated or bought second hand, and with the exchange rate. Get written quotations from several equipment suppliers for a stated working width and disc count, and ask separately what a replacement set of discs and bearings costs, because on a disc implement the wearing parts are a large part of what you will actually spend.

Offset or tandem for a small farm? A tandem if the main job is finishing a seedbed on reasonably level ground, because it runs straight and leaves the better surface for a planter. An offset if you need to work heavier residue, break tougher ground, or reach strips the tractor must stay off, and if your tractor can carry the extra weight. Offset harrows with heavy blades are used for primary tillage in their own right.

Do I always have to harrow after ploughing? On most Ugandan fields, yes, at least once. A ploughed field is a set of furrows and large clods, and a planter needs level ground and soil fine enough to close over seed. The exception is a rough dry season fallow furrow left open on purpose to catch the first rains, which gets harrowed later rather than straight away.

Is ploughing simply bad for the soil? Inversion tillage carries real costs, and the Ugandan measurements from Mukono are stark about them: the more the soil was opened, inverted and left bare, the more of the rain ran off and the more soil went with it. But the answer is not to swap a plough for a harrow, which builds its own pan higher up. It is fewer passes, varied working depth between seasons, tillage across the slope rather than down it, and keeping residue on the surface wherever a crop allows it.

Before buying either implement, write down your tractor's power rating, its linkage category measurements and its lift capacity, then ask at least three equipment suppliers for written quotations naming the disc count, disc diameter, working width, mass and stated minimum tractor power. Compare those against the listings under where to buy farm tractors and machinery, and ask each supplier what a replacement set of discs and bearings costs and whether they hold them. The implement that arrives with parts on a shelf nearby is usually the cheaper one by the end of its second season.

More in Farm Machinery