414 guides across 21 subjects
Every figure traced to a named source
Prices in Ugandan shillings, per acre and per animal

Silage Choppers

Tractors and a forage harvester working a field

Silage choppers cut standing forage into short lengths so it packs down tightly enough to ferment instead of rotting. They exist to solve one Ugandan problem, which is that milk collapses in the dry months and the grass that would have fixed it grew three months earlier. The machine is a few days of work a year. What it produces feeds a herd through the gap.

Uganda's Dry Season Feed Gap Is the Real Dairy Constraint

Ugandan dairy output is not limited by breed or by market access nearly as much as it is limited by what happens to feed between rains.

A survey of 150 farmers across seven south western districts, Mbarara, Isingiro, Kiruhura, Sheema, Bushenyi, Ntungamo and Lyantonde, recorded average milk at 9.0 litres per cow per day in the rainy season and 4.6 in the dry. The same cow, the same farm, roughly half the milk. An ILRI feed assessment in Maddu, Mpigi district, describes the mechanism on the ground: grazing is the primary feed component through most of the year and it drops sharply in the dry season of January and February. Nothing about the animal changed. The grass did.

What makes that worth a machine is what the same survey found among farms that had conserved forage. Cows receiving no silage or hay in the dry season gave 4.6 litres a day. Cows getting about 6.8 kilograms of silage a day gave 10.2, an increase of 5.6 litres or about 130 percent. Cows on about 7.8 kilograms of hay a day gave 8.9, up 4.3 litres or about 93 percent.

Dry season feeding Fed per cow daily Milk per cow daily
No conserved forage None 4.6 litres
Silage About 6.8 kg 10.2 litres
Hay About 7.8 kg 8.9 litres

Those are farm records from working Ugandan dairies rather than a trial, so they carry the usual caution that farms which conserve forage tend to do other things well too. The size of the gap still tells you where the constraint sits. Silage, on that evidence, roughly doubled dry season milk.

Where the Chopper Sits in Harvesting a Maize Silage Crop

FAO divides silage making into four stages: harvesting the forage, moving it to the silo, compacting it, and sealing it airtight. The silage chopper serves the first stage and enables the third, which is the relationship worth holding onto. It does not preserve anything by itself.

Chopping is first in importance among the treatments applied to forage before it is ensiled, ahead of wilting and conditioning, and FAO's reason is mechanical rather than nutritional. Chopping is what lets the material compact tightly enough to exclude air, which starts the fermentation quickly, and it makes better use of the space in the pit. Everything the chopper contributes runs through compaction.

Two machine positions exist. A stationary chopper sits at the silo and material is fed into it as the pit is filled, which is the normal Ugandan arrangement. A field machine chops as it collects, which is what tractor drawn and self propelled harvesters do. FAO's classes divide by cutting mechanism: impact machines with knives on a rotor chop to 6 to 10 centimetres at 8 to 10 tonnes an hour and suck soil in with the forage; rotating knife machines cut cleanly to 2 to 4 centimetres without damaging the regrowth; plate shear harvesters reach 15 to 20 tonnes an hour with chop length adjustable between 0.5 and 2 centimetres, and want flat ground. For almost every Ugandan smallholder the relevant one is a stationary chopper, and the relevant question is chop length rather than machine class.

Chop Length That Lets a Silage Crop Compact

The chop length for silage is set by how well the material packs, not by the cow. That is the difference from chopping forage for the trough, where the length is set by intake and rumination, and it is why silage is chopped shorter than you would feed.

Three sources converge on a narrow band. FAO's principles for good silage state that forage should be chopped into pieces no longer than 2 centimetres to allow good compaction and reduce air retention. The East African smallholder dairy feeding manual specifies fine chopping to 2 to 2.5 centimetres to allow compaction, and gives the same figure again for tube silage, not more than 2.5 centimetres. The Ugandan survey of south western dairy farms names 1 to 2.5 centimetres as the appropriate chop length, adding that it does not hold back silage uptake or milk yield.

Call it 1 to 2.5 centimetres and understand what sets the tighter end. The shorter the chop, the less force is needed to expel the air. FAO's specific warning is about wilted material: air can only be expelled properly from wilted forage if the particles are under 2 centimetres, and where the pieces are longer the remedy is to add a final layer of 10 to 15 centimetres of fresh green forage on top to weigh the material down before closing. So a farm compacting by foot needs a shorter chop than a farm compacting with a tractor, because the chop length is doing the work the tractor would otherwise do.

Chop length also buys a second thing, which is worth knowing without letting it change the setting. Material chopped to between 2 and 4 centimetres is easier for a cow to eat, regurgitate and ruminate. That is a feeding benefit riding along with a compaction decision rather than a reason to chop longer.

Why Excluding Air Decides Whether the Crop Ferments or Rots

Silage is not dried feed and it is not stored feed. It is a controlled fermentation, and the control is the absence of oxygen.

FAO's account of the process runs in four phases. In phase one, an aerobic phase lasting only hours, the oxygen trapped between the plant particles is used up by the plant's own respiration and by yeasts and enterobacteria, while the pH is still around 6.5 to 6.0. In phase two, once the mass has gone anaerobic, lactic acid bacteria take over and ferment the water soluble sugars into lactic acid, dropping the pH to somewhere between 3.8 and 5.0. Phase three is a stable phase that lasts for exactly as long as air is kept out. Phase four starts the moment silage meets air again.

Read that sequence for what it asks of the farmer, because two of the four phases are entirely in your hands and two are not. Filling well and quickly minimises the oxygen in phase one, which leaves more sugar available for the lactic acid bacteria in phase two instead of being burnt off by respiration. Phases two and three run themselves. Phase four is the one with a price tag on it: once silage is exposed to air, yeasts and acetic acid bacteria degrade the preserving acids, the pH rises, temperature rises, moulds and bacilli follow, and dry matter is lost at a rate FAO puts at 1.5 to 4.5 percent a day. That is the number that makes a small, quickly emptied pit better than a large slow one.

Which is why FAO's four golden rules for the process are all about pace and sealing rather than about quality of forage. Silo capacity has to match the material. The filling rate has to match how fast you can compact. The whole job should finish in one day and at worst three. And airtightness has to be absolute. FAO also advises against holding all of a farm's silage in one silo, recommending instead several that can each be emptied quickly, and feeding after roughly 60 to 70 days of conservation, which is long enough for the fermentation to have finished.

Chopper Throughput Against Pit Size and Herd Numbers

The useful way to size a chopper is to start from the pit, and the useful way to size the pit is to start from the animals.

FAO gives the arithmetic. An adult cow taking half of a 10 kilogram dry matter ration as silage eats 5 kilograms of silage dry matter a day. Over a 180 day feeding period that is 900 kilograms of silage dry matter, which at 25 percent dry matter is 3.6 tonnes of fresh forage. Allow 15 percent for losses and you need about 4.14 tonnes ensiled per cow, which at an assumed silage density of 0.6 tonnes per cubic metre is roughly 2.3 cubic metres of silo per cow. The same method for a goat at 0.6 kilograms a day gives about 0.83 cubic metres.

Multiply by the number of animals and you have the pit. Then the chopper has to fill it inside the time the golden rules allow, which is one day and at most three. Uganda's own equipment specification for forage choppers procured under its climate smart agriculture programme asks for at least 2 tonnes an hour from an engine driven machine of 7 to 16 horsepower, which gives a sense of what a serviceable stationary chopper delivers. Against a ten cow herd needing roughly 23 cubic metres, or in the order of 14 tonnes of fresh forage at that density, the chopping itself is not the bottleneck.

What does become the bottleneck is everything around the chopper. FAO's rule that the filling rate must match the compaction capacity cuts both ways: a chopper that outruns the people treading the pit produces loosely packed silage, which is worse than a slower fill. Layers should go in no thicker than 20 centimetres each. Compaction by a person walking suits vertical silos of 2 tonnes or less and horizontal silos under 4 metres wide, and mechanical compaction needs a silo at least 4 metres wide to get a tractor in. And material has to lie at least 40 centimetres deep, because conservation will not happen in a thinner layer no matter how well it is covered.

Harvest Stage and Dry Matter Before the Chopper Runs

A chopper cannot fix a crop cut at the wrong time, and in Uganda this is where silage most often fails before the machine is even started.

The dry matter of the fresh crop decides whether the fermentation has anything to work with. The East African feeding manual sets a floor of above 20 percent dry matter in the fresh crop for a silage crop, along with enough water soluble sugars and a physical structure that packs. FAO's own guidance says not to ensile material below 25 percent dry matter in a barrel or vertical silo. A tropical silage review co-authored at Makerere University is stricter about the risk: ensiling material below 30 percent dry matter can create conditions that suit the wrong micro-organisms rather than the lactic acid bacteria you want, and wilting to 30 to 35 percent prevents effluent, suppresses undesirable organisms and raises intake.

Wilting has its own cost and it is not free. Respiration losses during field wilting run at roughly 2 percent of dry matter a day, and effluent losses from material ensiled too wet run at 2 to 10 percent and take the most soluble and digestible nutrients with them. So the target is not the driest possible crop, it is the window.

Harvest stage sets the sugar. Maize and sorghum go in at the dough stage, when the grain is milky, and at that point they carry enough water soluble sugar that no molasses is needed. Napier grass is cut at about a metre high, when protein is around 10 percent, and it does need molasses because it does not carry enough sugar of its own. The manual's dry matter yields give a sense of how much land a pit represents: roughly 4 to 12 tonnes an acre for Napier, 6.8 to 8.8 for sorghum, 9.6 for maize.

Pit, Bags and Plastic: The Storage a Chopper Needs

The chopper is one line in a shopping list, and buying it without the rest produces chopped grass rather than silage.

The container can be almost anything that seals. FAO lists steel and plastic barrels, two metre concrete water pipes, and thick plastic packing sacks of the kind fertiliser comes in, and notes that on a small farm receptacles down to 200 litres filled by hand make effective silos. Ugandan farms mostly use pit silos, with a minority using polythene tube silage. Both work.

The plastic sheet is the part that gets economised and should not be. It need not be one piece, and FAO explicitly allows sheets from previous packaging so long as they overlap enough and the whole silo is covered. Weights on top can be old tyres filled with concrete, bags of sand or earth, or a grid of steel or wooden bars with weights on it. What cannot be improvised is the seal itself, because phase four starts wherever air gets in.

Where a tube or bag is used, filling and compaction are done by hand with care not to damage the sides, and a puncture is repaired with adhesive plastic tape rather than ignored. Rats and rodents are a real risk to bagged silage, so it wants shade and a store rather than a yard.

FAO's worked routine for a two tonne small farm silage day, two people plus a cart and a stationary chopper. Ten hours, start to sealed.
Cutting the forage by hand, about 3 hours. The single longest job and the one to recruit help for.
Loading, about 1 hour. Cut only what can be moved the same day, or respiration starts eating the sugar.
Transport, about 1 hour for a two kilometre round trip. Longer hauls change the whole plan.
Chopping, about 1 hour. This is the machine's entire contribution to the day.
Filling and compacting, about 3 hours. Layers of 20 centimetres, trodden until the material under your foot sinks no more than 2 centimetres.
Sealing, about 1 hour. Dome the top, cover, weight it down, and walk the edges checking for gaps.

Labour Concentrated Into Two or Three Days of Harvest

Silage making is not a daily job like chopping forage for the trough. It is a short, brutal, once or twice a year job, and that shape is what farms get wrong.

The routine above accounts for ten person hours for two tonnes, and the pit for a ten cow herd is several times that. Because the golden rules require the silo to be filled and sealed inside one day, at worst three, the work cannot be spread out. It has to be done with enough hands on the day, which means arranging labour in advance rather than discovering the problem halfway through filling.

The Ugandan cost data bears out how large that block is. Across the surveyed silage making farms, labour was roughly half the total cost of making silage, covering land preparation, planting, weeding and harvesting. For hay on the same survey it was a much larger share still. Whatever a chopper costs, the labour around it costs more, and the arithmetic that decides whether silage is worth making is a labour arithmetic.

Two practical consequences. Hiring a chopper for two days is often a better decision than buying one, because the machine sits idle for the rest of the year while the labour bill recurs. And a group of neighbours sharing one machine and turning out for each other's filling day solves the labour problem and the utilisation problem in the same move, which is why chopper hire and group arrangements are common wherever silage is actually made.

Where Ugandan Silage Making Actually Goes Wrong

The same Ugandan survey watched farms make silage and recorded the failures, which is more useful than any list of best practice.

The headline finding is uncomfortable. Only 5 of 32 visited farms harvested maize for silage at the recommended stage, and the study notes that the too early stage was the one Ugandan livestock extension providers were routinely recommending. Maize cut before the dough is ripe has not accumulated the energy in the cob, so the silage is lower in feed value and ferments poorly, and a farmer following the advice they were given ends up with the wrong crop in the pit.

The second finding is about the pit rather than the crop. Regardless of whether farms used pit silos or polythene bags, compaction was poorly done and most of the silage appeared relatively mouldy. That is phase one and phase four failing at both ends: air left in the mass at filling, and air getting back in during storage.

Both failures are worth sitting with, because neither is a machine problem. A better chopper does not fix a crop cut a fortnight early, and it does not tread the pit for you. What a shorter chop does is make the compaction easier to achieve with the force a farm actually has, which is feet.

Five ways a silage pit fails, and the sign that tells you which one happened.
Cut too early. Low energy silage from a maize crop whose grain was still watery. The tell is a thin, sharp smelling silage the cows eat without gaining.
Chopped too long. Air trapped between stems that no amount of treading expels. The tell is mould through the body of the pit, not just at the edges.
Ensiled too wet. Effluent seeping from the base, taking the soluble nutrients with it, and a butyric smell.
Filled too slowly. Sugar burnt off by respiration before the mass went anaerobic, so the pH never fell far enough.
Sealed badly or opened too wide. Mould and heating at the surface and the face, with dry matter disappearing at 1.5 to 4.5 percent a day wherever air reaches.
Judging a pit when you open it, using the criteria in the East African dairy feeding manual.
Colour. Good silage is bright or light yellow green. Brown means it overheated, which points at poor sealing.
Smell. A vinegar like smell is right. Rancid butter or ammonia is wrong and means the fermentation went the other way.
Texture. Firm. Slimy or soapy material has fermented badly.
Feeding. Feed silage to milking cows after milking rather than before, to keep off flavours out of the milk.

Choosing a Silage Chopper for a Ugandan Dairy Farm

Because silage is a two day a year job, the first question is not which chopper but whether to own one at all.

Hiring makes sense for a farm making one or two pits a year, and a shared or group owned machine makes sense for a cluster of farms filling in sequence. Owning makes sense where the same machine also does the daily feeding chop, which is the common Ugandan case and the strongest argument for buying: one machine, two jobs, one of them daily.

Where you do buy, the specification that matters for silage is narrower than the one that matters for feeding. Chop length has to reach the 1 to 2.5 centimetre band and hold it, which means an adjustable length range and blades kept sharp rather than a single nominal setting. Throughput has to fill your pit inside the sealing window, and Uganda's own procurement standard of at least 2 tonnes an hour is a reasonable floor to hold a supplier to. The drive has to match what the farm has, and Uganda's specification assumes a petrol or diesel engine rather than mains electricity. And the machine has to be movable to the pit, since a stationary chopper that cannot reach the silo turns into a carrying problem.

The rest of the equipment decision, the build quality, the guarding and the daily use case, belongs with the feeding machine rather than this one, and is covered on the chaff cutter page. What is specific to silage is the length, the throughput against the pit, and everything that has to be bought alongside the machine.

Silage Chopper Questions From Ugandan Dairy Farmers

What does a silage chopper cost in Uganda? There is no figure here worth printing, because every shilling amount in circulation for a chopper traces back to somebody selling one and none of them could be checked. What can be said is that the chopper is often not the largest line in the job. Put one written specification, covering chop length range, throughput, drive type and a spare blade set, in front of three or more suppliers, and collect hire rates from a local owner or group in the same conversation, since hiring for two days is frequently the better answer. Treat any amount you are shown as valid only on the day you are shown it.

What does it cost to make a tonne of silage in Uganda? The seven district survey put the average cost of the silage its farms made at about 131,000 shillings a tonne, with the hay on the same survey working out higher at around 155,000. Labour was roughly half the silage cost and by far the largest share of the hay cost. Those are averages across a small number of case study farms and they will not be your numbers, but the structure holds: the largest line is people, not machinery or inputs.

Is silage worth the trouble financially? On that survey's own arithmetic, yes, and by a wide margin. Each tonne of silage fed returned in the order of 820 litres of additional milk, and at the average farm gate price the farms were receiving the margin came out at roughly 725,000 shillings a tonne, rising to about 940,000 at the highest price in the study. Hay returned less, near 435,000 a tonne. Treat those as what those farms achieved rather than as a promise, and note that they assume the additional milk holds steady across the feeding period.

How short should I chop for silage, and is that the same as for feeding? No, it is shorter. For silage, aim at 1 to 2.5 centimetres, which is where FAO's no longer than 2 centimetres, the East African dairy manual's 2 to 2.5, and the Ugandan survey's 1 to 2.5 all sit. The length is chosen for compaction rather than for the cow, and a farm packing the pit by foot rather than by tractor needs the shorter end of that band. Chopping for the daily trough is a different setting and a different reason.

How big a pit do I need? Work it from the animals. FAO's method gives roughly 2.3 cubic metres per adult cow for a 180 day feeding period, assuming silage makes up half the ration and a silage density of 0.6 tonnes per cubic metre, and about 0.83 cubic metres per goat on the same basis. Multiply by your numbers, then split the total across more than one silo rather than building a single large one, because a pit you can empty quickly loses far less at the face.

Why did my silage go mouldy? Almost always air, arriving at one of two points. Either it was never expelled during filling, which comes from too long a chop, layers packed too thick, compaction done half heartedly, or a fill spread over too many days. Or it got back in during storage through a torn sheet, a poorly weighted cover or too wide an open face. A Ugandan survey of dairy farms found compaction poorly done and most silage relatively mouldy regardless of whether pits or bags were used, so you are in common company, and the fix is mechanical rather than chemical.

Do I need molasses or an additive? It depends on the crop, and the rule is about sugar. Maize and sorghum cut at the dough stage carry enough water soluble sugar on their own. Napier grass does not, which is why molasses is normally added when ensiling it, and most Ugandan silage making farms in the survey did use it. Where a rate is needed, the East African dairy manual gives about 9 kilograms of molasses per tonne of silage; any commercial inoculant or additive carries its own rate on the label and that is the rate to follow rather than a general figure.

Can I make silage from Napier alone, or do I need maize? Napier alone works and is common, with the caveat that it needs added sugar to ferment properly. The Ugandan survey found the highest energy silage on its sampled farms was Napier grass treated with molasses, at 10.2 megajoules per kilogram, ahead of everything else it measured. Maize gives more dry matter per acre, roughly 9.6 tonnes against 4 to 12 for Napier, and needs no molasses at the dough stage, but it occupies the land for a season. Napier is already standing on most zero grazing farms, which usually settles the question.

How long before I can feed it? Allow roughly 60 to 70 days of conservation, which FAO gives as the point at which fermentation has run properly and the risk of aerobic deterioration is lowest. Opening early gets you partly fermented material and starts the spoilage clock before the feed gap arrives.

Can I use the same machine as my chaff cutter? Often yes, and that is the strongest reason to buy rather than hire, because it turns a two day a year machine into a daily one. The requirement is an adjustable chop length that reaches both the short silage band and the longer feeding length, which is worth confirming on the machine rather than on the leaflet.

When you are ready, compare equipment suppliers and local hire rates side by side against one written specification, and get the chop length range, the throughput, the drive and the spare blade set confirmed in writing before committing, since the pit, the sheet and the labour all have to be arranged around whatever you settle on. Put the harvest stage question to a dairy extension worker or your district production office before the machine is booked, because the survey above found that advice is where Ugandan silage most often goes wrong. Neighbouring equipment topics are indexed on the farm machinery hub, the method itself is covered in silage making for dairy cattle, and the alternative route through the dry season is set out in the hay making guide. For the crops that fill a pit, read Napier grass farming and Brachiaria grass farming, the milk side of the argument is in how to increase milk production, the daily feeding chop is covered under chaff cutters, and the whole enterprise budget sits in the cost of dairy farming.

More in Farm Machinery